Thursday, October 8, 2015

OFF THE RAILS OR THEATRICAL TRAIN WRECKS Part Two

OFF THE RAILS OR THEATRICAL TRAIN WRECKS
Part Two

These next three shows all went off the rails in Chicago. I suspect a lot of folks won't agree with the second one featured today, but…

Go grab some coffee and let's get started.


THE KID FROM BROOKLYN – Mercury Theater, Chicago


June, 2008. This terrible, terrible waste of time purported to tell the story of Danny Kaye…womanizer, alleged homophobic closeted homosexual and abrasive performer. Instead of actually giving us a portrait of Danny Kaye, warts and all, since someone's "faults" often make that person more interesting, this endeavor played like a rabid fanboy's homage to his idol. To his credit, Kaye was very active in charitable organizations, but watching this, I got the impression that Kaye did nothing without first determining whether or not it would be good for his career. As portrayed here, Kaye's wife, Sylvia Fine, didn't appear to be much better. In Karin Leone's performance, she came off as a coldly shrewd and calculating woman, an impression not dissipated by Fine's hosting gigs for television specials in the 80s celebrating Broadway musicals, where she appeared distant, aloof, even a bit superior. Full disclosure, I know my opinion of this production is largely tempered by the fact that Danny Kaye gave the single most unprofessional and disrespectful performance I have seen to date when I had the great misfortune of seeing him in Two By Two after his accident, when all pretenses of character and honoring the material had been jettisoned. Credit where credit is due, the cast of four worked hard, especially Brian Childers as Kaye. But all that hard work was for naught. Judging by audience reaction at the performance I attended, the crowd either loved the show or hated it. Interval chatter was evenly split. The Chicago reviews were decidedly on the negative side. Of the ten shows that make up my list of theatrical train wrecks, this is the only one that was chosen solely on a visceral, emotional response. God, did I hate this show! – at the Mercury Theater, Chicago
Sidebar: Although inconceivable to me, a similarly-themed musical called Danny and Sylvia: The Danny Kaye Musical (in an earlier workshop incarnation it was called Danny and Sylvia: A Musical Love Story) opened off-Broadway about a year after the run of The Kid from Brooklyn. Although the producers of D and S were quick to tell prospective audiences not to be confused with TKFB, both shows starred Brian Childers, which leaves one to wonder if Danny Kaye is all that Mr. Childers has in his theatrical bag of tricks. On a reduced four-performance-per-week schedule and heavy on matinees, D and S ran for nearly three years. Really?

JEKYLL & HYDE – Shubert Theatre, Chicago

 


 Brad Oscar was in the cast. He'd go on to do far better things.
 This was the line-up in Chicago. It would be different by the time the show reached NYC.


"Eder is the Streisand of the 90's." Uh...well....


The New York marquee was striking.

January, 1996. Two sell-out engagements at Houston's Alley Theatre and a wildly popular concept album made up the hype that preceded this hugely-anticipated musical's arrival at the Shubert, midway through an unofficial, yet nobody was denying it, pre-Broadway tour. It opened. It received poor reviews. It played to adoring audiences. It was a mess. Starring Robert Cuccioli as Jekyll/Hyde and Linda Eder as prostitute-with-a-heart-of-gold Lucy Harris (paging Shirley MacLaine), then composer Frank Wildhorn's paramour, then wife, then ex-wife, the show musicalized Robert Lewis Stevenson's classic novella about split personalities and the good and evil that coexist in people, a theme that, on the surface seems, a natural for a Gothic, Victorian confection of a musical. Instead, however, creators Frank Wildhorn and Leslie Bricusse created a show that was a great, big, gooey, cheesy, pseudo-Gothic hot mess of a show with all the subtlety of a baseball bat to the head, enough power ballads to make Les Misérables blush, a plethora of swinging heads and bouncing hair (the means by which Mr. Cuccioli changed from the saintly Dr. Jekyll into the demonic Mr. Hyde, who was, frankly, by far the more interesting of the dual personalities), a sound system that was set on very LOUD, and a stultifyingly wooden performance by Linda Eder. Now let me state flat out that Mr. Cuccioli did his best, delivering a solid performance backed up by a good voice, and I suppose all that hair tossing was the only workable way to do the multiple personality switches called for in the script, but he was saddled with a dreary, pedestrian script and wasn't helped by a production that lacked inspiration from both director and choreographer.. As good girl Lisa Carew, soprano Christiane Noll, making her Broadway debut in this show and who would create, a decade later, a powerful Mother in the revival of Ragtime, was the only principal who created a character of nuance. Her Act Two duet with Ms. Eder, "In His Eyes," was the highlight of the evening and she easily stole the song and the stage from Linda Eder. So what specifically made this show a top-ten theatrical train wreck? Well, several things actually, but first let me state that I was sincerely looking forward to this show and was, up to then, somewhat of a fan of the concept album. Yes, the same overwrought power ballads, but one can adjust the volume in one's living room. And while all that overwrought-ness can work in a recording, on stage it all becomes too much. So that was working against the show. And then there was the matter of Ms. Eder's performance. Ms. Eder is a singer with a fiercely loyal and devoted fan base and a powerful set of pipes (I find her one-note...loud…, but I'm probably in the minority on that one.), but is woefully lacking in the acting department. Watching her dialogue scenes bordered on painful. I didn't care that she sang/bellowed/beat-to-a-bloody-pulp her songs and made them all sound alike. Blame Mr. Wildhorn for composing songs that all blend together. What I still can't overlook is that she was the lead in a Broadway-bound musical and simply didn't have the chops for it. I'm sure her relationship with Wildhorn played a part in the casting, but it didn't work with Andrew Lloyd Webber's then-wife Sarah Brightman in The Phantom of the Opera, and it didn't work here. A pretty and powerful voice alone is not a sound reason to cast someone, nor will it hide acting deficiencies. Why didn't the producers seek out an actress who can sing with the best of them? Karen Ziemba immediately comes to mind, and, even now, just thinking what she could have brought to that role, well, it makes me want to weep at the missed opportunity. The combination of cheesy production values, sound-alike music, hair-tossing, and terrible acting all came to a head in the penultimate scene. The action takes place in Lucy's digs, a bright, virginal white room and our Lucy is dressed in a bright, virginal white dress. Are we getting the symbolism here? The room is spotless. SPOTLESS. Eder brays out a power ballad where she longs for "A New Life." Pretty, and loud, but nothing we haven't heard throughout the evening. Cuccioli, in his flowing locks as Hyde, enters. Insipid dialogue ensues, then, cradling Lucy, he stabs her as the stage blood flows a deep red in this bright, virginal white environment. Stop it! Now! But the worst offense and the moment when the show entered the hallowed ranks of theatrical train wrecks, was the Act Two opener, "Murder, Murder," an ensemble number so terrible in execution that it actually elicited laughs. I came back from intermission for this? It ranks right up there with "Louis Says" from Victor/Victoria as one of the worst musical numbers ever. Lots of missed opportunities. I would love to see Sondheim or Jason Robert Brown tackle this story. – at the Shubert Theatre, Chicago
Sidebar: A year after the unofficial, yet nobody was denying it, pre-Broadway tour, Jekyll & Hyde, opened in New York at the Plymouth Theatre and ran for nearly four years. In the intervening time between Chicago and New York, the entire production and design staff had been replaced, songs dropped, shifted around and added, but the show still, as then, didn't meet with critical favor. That, however, didn't faze the audiences who flocked to the Plymouth, especially the "Jekkies," superfans of the show, the Jekyll & Hyde version of Deadheads, who were a fixture at the Plymouth. The show was filmed featuring the final cast starring, wait for it, David Hasselhof, out of his swim trunks and onto the stage, as Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde. Despite the long run and over 1500 performances, the original run closed at a substantial loss (roughly 25% according to Playbill.com). Linda Eder continues to this day to have a successful career as a singer, but, except for concert engagements, has not since acted on Broadway. Frank Wildhorn, after seven attempts, if one counts the 2013 revival of J&H, has yet to have a financial, or critical, success on the Great White Way, but he still slogs away at it. Having said all this, however, there's no need to cry for Mr. Wildhorn or Mr. Bricusse. The show has had numerous productions in the States and abroad and is popular with amateur and regional theatres. I'm sure by now the original run has more than paid back its investment.

********************
INTERVAL --- What was going on in Chicago Theatre in 1996.
The guy's hot enough to make me wish I'd seen it. Puck and Bottom, indeed!

Don't know how I missed this. The play is a great old chestnut and the cast certainly was starry enough.


How to Succeed was delightful. I would rather eat ground glass than see Jerry Lewis in anything.

********************


ODYSSEY – Arie Crown Theatre, Chicago

Oh, Joan! The eye makeup! Noooo! And, maybe it's just me, but Yul has this gay-boy-just-leaving-the-gym look. I should have known what was coming.



Any of these would have been better than Odyssey. Quite a variety of venues and plays/musicals going on. And, yes, starring in The Magic Man was that David Copperfield. Only 21 and smoking hot. Sadly, however, we must return to Odyssey.

May, 1975. Even the biggest stars and creative talents in the business can have their bad days. In the case of Odyssey, some of the business' biggest stars and creative talents had some really, really bad days. This horror of a show had music by Man of La Mancha's Mitch Leigh and book and lyrics by Erich ”Love Story" Segal. It was directed by La Mancha's director, Albert Marre and starred Marre's wife and La Mancha's original Aldonza, Joan Diener and, oh-my-GOD!!, the King himself, Yul Brynner. Well, suffice it to say that there was no "Impossible Dream" this time around and this intermissionless and interminable two-hour fright of a musical was as perfect an example of "what were they thinking?" that you could find. I think the idea was to convert Homer's epic poem "The Odyssey" into, and I quote the program here, "a new musical comedy." I'm sorry. I just don't think of Homer and immediately go, "Break out the tap shoes, Mickey and Judy! It's show time!!" The score, such as it was, was derivative, in the worst sense of the word; Erich Segal proved that not only could he not write fiction, he couldn't write lyrics or a musical libretto either (I so wanted to do a riff on "Love means never having to say you're sorry" here, but my mind did a complete blank.); Albert Marre's direction was pretty much non-existent; Joan Diener's deportment was that of a queen dispensing largesse to the peasants, though one couldn't deny the power of her famed voice; Yul Brynner acted as though he desperately wanted to break into a quick rendition of "A Puzzlement," etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. (see The King and I). Even talented Russ Thacker, there primarily, I think, for the sole purpose of providing eye candy, seemed lost at sea here, no pun intended. Playing at the gigantic Arie Crown Theatre, it played to huge crowds, thanks to Brynner, received negative reviews, thanks to a crappy show, and left me scratching my head in bewilderment. Truly an awful, awful show. Not bad enough to be one of the great legendary flops; just bad. Full stop.– at the Arie Crown Theatre, Chicago
Sidebar: At the end of Odyssey's year-long tour, it limped into the Palace Theatre in New York under its new name of Home Sweet Homer, where it opened on a Sunday matinee and promptly closed that same afternoon. By that time, Erich Segal was no longer associated with the show. Lucky him. The tour was full of strife, terrible reviews, missed performances by the leads and a general sense that somebody needed to say "Enough!" But nobody did. Man of La Mancha would prove to be Mitch Leigh's only success as a Broadway composer. (Not that he needed to ever again write another note, but still.) For the husband-and-wife team of Albert Marre and Joan Diener, La Mancha would be their final success, both individually and together. Both would revisit La Mancha in various productions and revivals. Yul Brynner would scamper happily back to playing the King in cross-country tours and in two hugely successful Broadway revivals of The King and I. Russ Thacker had a modestly successful career, but the Broadway portion of it was littered with quick-closing flops. Odyssey/Home Sweet Homer … lots of wasted time, talent and money.

Tune in next time for the last three shows of my top-ten theatrical train wrecks.

© 2015 Jeffrey Geddes

Sunday, September 20, 2015

OFF THE RAILS OR THEATRICAL TRAIN WRECKS Part One

OFF THE RAILS OR THEATRICAL TRAIN WRECKS
Part One

I've been going to professional theatre productions since 1966. That's nearly a half century now. (Okay, that just really sunk in. Wow.) Over those nearly fifty years, I've seen my share of really, really bad shows, the theatrical equivalent of train wrecks. But, as I mentioned in an earlier post, I truly believe no one in the theatre wakes up one morning, pours a cup of coffee, and proclaims, "I'm going to write/produce/act in/design/direct a rotten show!"  Who has the time to do this?  Who has the money to do this?  I believe all theatre projects start out with the best of intentions. Somewhere along the way, however, things go south, the folks involved, for whatever reasons, can't (unfixable material) or won't (big blinders, bigger egos, and even bigger delusions that everything is fine) fix the situation, and, inevitably, disaster occurs.

A case in point: back in the late 80s, an acquaintance of mine opened a musical on Broadway. The show received savage reviews and closed quickly. A million or so dollars down the drain; a dozen or so actors out of a job. What went wrong? For starters, a troubled and confrontational gestation period that, if anything, only got worse during the show's tryout and, sadly, continued and worsened through its preview period and short Broadway run. Add to the mix the inexperience of the show's creators, which resulted in a listless book and a mostly forgettable score. ("Mostly" because the score does offer up two really good songs.) Top if off with a production that looked cheap and substandard. And as a final touch, a hapless cast struggling with the material compounded by a barely competent performance by its leading lady. But it didn't start out that way. Like all new shows, hopes and spirits were high. But then, but then…

All of the shows I'll chat about in these next three posts started out with the best of intentions. Many of these shows were written by/directed by/starring top names in the business, folks who know or should know quality material. What all of these shows lacked, however, was the truly objective voice that could say, "STOP!! Danger, Will Robinson, danger!" and the results were hot theatrical messes that confounded both its audiences and its critics. In the theatre, far more shows fail financially than succeed in making their money back. Some fail so spectacularly they become legendary, a part of theatrical lore. Breakfast at Tiffany's, Carrie, and Moose Murders immediately come to mind. Most, however, simply close and are rarely thought of again. Some of the shows I'll write about ran for a long time, but didn't make money, and others were barely a blip on the theatrical radar. These are my top ten theatrical train wrecks. Shows that truly went "off the rails."


Let's begin.

WILD AND WONDERFUL – Lyceum Theatre, New York



November, 1971. First preview/world premiere! Neither wild nor wonderful, for forty years, this justly-forgotten musical was my gold standard for theatrical train wrecks. The impetus to see this show was Walter Willison, who I saw a few months earlier in the pedestrian Richard Rodgers' musical, Two by Two. He was the bright spot in the show, talented, only a few years older than me, cute as all get out, and, frankly, I had a bit of a crush on him. I was excited at the prospect of seeing the very first performance of his new musical. By the time the curtain fell on that first preview performance, I was far less than excited and knew that I had just witnessed a monumental flop. And, boys and girls, it was monumental. Terrible book, terrible score, terrible production values, terrible direction, terrible choreography. Why anyone ever thought this material should be produced on Broadway is beyond me. You know you're in trouble when the book writers' and the composer's Playbill bios are all terribly vague and say things like "he has written for the theatre for many years both off and on Broadway" or "he has been directing television programs for CBS" and no titles are offered. The plot, if one can truly call it that, involved the CIA (I kid you not. One of the songs was titled "I Spy.") with the horribly misused Willison cast as a cool and hip spy dude assigned to infiltrate the radical youth of the very early 70s. Toss in a winsome lass who Cool and Hip Spy Dude mistakes for a radical bomber for reasons that make absolutely no sense. Then add in Roman Catholic clerics for that touch of religion and, well, you get the picture. It was a mess…fascinating and horrifying to watch at the same time. But, if every cloud indeed has a silver lining, Wild and Wonderful had one sensational silver lining in Laura McDuffie, who, in her Broadway debut, had the misfortune of being cast as the female lead, but who somehow managed to add dignity, charm, and huge amounts of talent to this disaster of a show. I was totally mad about her. The fact that Wild and Wonderful marked not only her Broadway debut, but also her Broadway farewell, was a great loss for Broadway. Had her debut show been even a modest success, I think she could have had a long and successful career in New York. So, why, you ask, was this show secure and relatively unchallenged for decades as the worst show I'd ever seen? I guess I'd have to say because this simply should not have been produced. It was amateur hour and a lot of money, talent, and time was wasted. Lots of worthier projects go unproduced, yet something like this somehow finds backing. I'm still shaking my head about this one. Oh…and Walter Willison? Well, he was still cute and all, but I moved on. Willison did, too, to a nice long stay in Pippin. Wild and Wonderful played nine previews, then opened to disastrous reviews and closed that night eight days after the performance I saw. 
Fun Factoids: Wild and Wonderful was produced under something called the Broadway Limited Gross Contract, a now defunct contract designed for productions scaled to earn less the $25,000 per week. (!!) Remember, this was in 1971. It offered lower union pay scales and, I believe, work rule concessions to promote production of smaller, more intimate shows. Top price for Wild and Wonderful was $5.00!  Even in 1971, that was a bargain. Another fun factoid, singer and Barbra Streisand sound-alike Julie Budd was supposed to make her Broadway debut in Wild and Wonderful. She dropped out shortly before previews began and Laura McDuffie took over. According to IBDB, Budd has only appeared on Broadway once in something called Catskills on Broadway. Sounds terrible, but at least she dodged the  W&W bullet. And one last fun factoid, in the ensemble was a young Ann Reinking in her second Broadway appearance. This was before she became Gwen Verdon's doppelgänger.

LESTAT – Palace Theatre, New York




One of my favorite actors, Will Swenson, was in the ensemble and one of the understudies for Lestat. He's gone on to far better things.

The hapless principals of Lestat. They tried; they really tried!

(edited from an earlier post)
May, 2006.  A score by Elton John and Bernie Taupin (together again!) based on Anne Rice's sensational vampire books and starring Hugh Panaro and Carolee Carmello?  Hell, I would have invested in this. The West Coast tryout made a crapload of money at San Francisco's Curran Theatre despite receiving cool/negative reviews, though Variety gave the show a very qualified, modestly positive notice.  Before opening in New York, Lestat underwent massive changes and anticipation was high, though how much of that anticipation was hoping for a hit or, based on the out-of-town reviews, hoping for disaster is moot. The show opened after a month of previews, received blisteringly sarcastic and box-office killing reviews, and closed after five struggling weeks. How bad was it?  Well, to be honest, it was pretty dreadful, but, there were many nice moments throughout the show.  The score had one strikingly beautiful number in "Sail Me Away," Hugh Panaro's performance was first-rate  (and he's soooo easy on the eyes and has that wonderful voice!), and it had a fine physical environment.  But one just could not escape the fact that the plot elements of the show just never coalesced into a cohesive whole. Perhaps the mistake was using both Interview with the Vampire and Lestat as the primary source material. Perhaps author Linda Woolverton would have been better served by sticking to just Lestat. After all, he is the title character. Anne Rice's vampire books are loaded with gothic horror, steamy romance, and hot homoeroticism, and face it, who wouldn't want Hugh Panaro to bite on your neck?, but all three elements were in short supply on the Palace stage. It wasn't necessarily dull; it just sort of sat there, inert and pretty lifeless. The cast was earnest and did their best, but there was one, well, I wouldn't call it an exception, but it sort of stood out for all the wrong reasons. Carolee Carmello, as Lestat's mom, was just as game and earnest as everyone else, but seemed so wrong in this part, so out of step with the rest of the proceedings. Understand, I love Carolee Carmello, but here she was just…off. For example, at one point, after she had been turned into a vampire by her loving son who just couldn't say goodbye to dying Mom, she enthusiastically attacked a hapless victim with scenery-chewing fervor and the audience laughed, which I don't think was the response the creators were going for. (Lest you think the audience was mean, the laugh was honest. The scene was overacted to such a degree, it was not even vaguely terrifying, which was, I think, the desired effect.) Lestat is one of my top theatrical train wrecks because it could have and should have been so much better with all the talent and source material involved.  Sad, sad, sad.
Fun Factoid: Hugh Panaro is one of the stars in an unassuming, gay-themed film from 1997 called Broadway Damage. It's one of my favorites. It's sweet, has a heart, is about theatre and has a charming cast. Panaro plays a somewhat nasty, unsympathetic character, but he's so good-looking, you don't really care.

NORMA DOESMEN – Abingdon Theatre, New York



March, 2010. Appallingly bad. Offensively bad. Relentlessly bad. A sexy, naughty spoof on the film classic Sunset Boulevard on paper seemed like a pleasant enough diversion for a March Saturday  afternoon, especially since it starred famed Judy Garland impersonator Tommy Femia as Norma Doesmen. Get it…"Doesmen." Hahahahahaha. How about "Joe Dillis" or even better, "Betty Shaveher"? Hahahahahahaha. Yes, yes, I know. We should have known better. Back when I first started going to New York in the 70s, it was still possible to produce a show off-Broadway for a relatively low cost and many shows were produced by playwrights, composers, actors, etc. to showcase their oftentimes dubious talents. These were called vanity productions. To call Norma Doesmen a vanity production is an insult to vanity productions. There really wasn't a redeeming feature in this trash, though, to be fair, I will admit the first few minutes appeared promising. It quickly, very quickly, went downhill. The so-called writer and director, Stephen Stahl, has a bio that fills up an entire page, yes, I said page, of the program. Seriously, dude? Who do you think you are? Mitzi Gaynor? (Inside joke. Mitzi Gaynor's bio in a concert Playbill was over 1 1/2 pages. Mitzi Gaynor? Please.) Credit where credit is due, you have some good credits, but, sweetcakes, a full page? That sort of self-aggrandizement reeks of vanity gone amuck. Except for Femia, the other three actors were making debuts, either off-Broadway or NYC itself. I don't know if they've gone on to do other things, but this was not an especially auspicious way to make a debut. We fled at the interval. We would have left earlier had we not been bogged down with shopping bags filled with goodies for our newborn granddaughter and the noise made by bags rattling, etc. would have been rude. Our departure meant the house would number twelve for the second act. If those twelve were smart, they would have followed our lead. In case you're wondering, the reason this didn't trump Wild and Wonderful as the leader was because W&W actually thought it had the goods to be a Broadway-caliber musical; Norma Doesmen's aspirations were more modest. It still sucked. Full stop.

VICTOR/VICTORIA – Shubert Theatre, Chicago


Hillel Gitter as "Mr. Balloon Man." Who is this person, you ask? According to his bio, he's a "citizen of the world" (spare me) and does something horrifically called "Clowntomime." Mimes AND clowns? That's just so inexcusably wrong in so many ways.

Christopher Innvar, who understudied King Marchan and was in the ensemble, would be a very, very good File in the Roundabout revival of 110 in the Shade a few years later.

It wasn't Julie's fault. It wasn't. Well, maybe a little.

July, 1995. Victor/Victoria is one of my favorite movies and hands-down my favorite Julie Andrews one. The film is sharp and sophisticated, lovely and lush to look at, with top-notch performances and a vibrant score. At the time I believed it to be a natural to transfer to the stage, so I was very excited when Victor/Victoria announced a pre-Broadway tryout in Chicago that would star Julie Andrews in her first Broadway appearance in over thirty years. Sadly, my initial excitement as the lights went down and the overture began quickly turned to bewilderment ("That wasn't very good. I hope it gets better.") to dismay ("What are they doing?") to complete disappointment ("Wow. What the hell happened?"). Excising "Gay Paree" and "The Shady Lady from Seville" and replacing them with the vastly inferior "Paris By Night" and, oh dear God in heaven, shoot me now, "Louis Says" was not only a major misstep, it was just plain stupid. The ill-advised revamp of "Le Jazz Hot," which actually got applause when I saw the film at the McClurg Court, turned this show-stopper for Julie Andrews into a song about the ensemble and Ms. Andrews sitting on top of a piano, while in the process tossing out all of the film's spectacular staging. To add insult to injury, Andrews' thrilling high note at the end of the song was pre-recorded, obviously and clumsily added, and basically smacked down the number. Now, granted, the song was pitched at least a third lower than the film version, but if Andrews could no longer hit that note, why not just give her a good belting high note that she could hold forever and let her honestly bring the number home? Obviously, money was not an issue and the production looked expensive. The cast consisted of theatre pros, but, and I really, really, really do hate film/stage (or stage/film) comparisons, the stage principals, including, oddly, Andrews, just did not come close to the film's originators. Closest was the always-charming Gregory Jbara. Tony Roberts, who is consistently professional, but not consistently interesting, was a flat Toddy; Rachel York, and I'm a Rachel York fan, was shrill and one-note as Norma (and her number "Paris Makes Me …", the ellipsis standing in for the word "horny," which apparently Playbill thought was too saucy a word for 1995 Chicago audiences, didn't help her at all); Michael Nouri was handsome, but bland. Even Andrews seemed tired. Don't get me wrong. She worked her butt off and was always every inch the star, but there was a lack of freshness that surprised me. The less said about the Act Two horror "Louis Says", the better. Direction seemed unfocused; the choreography seemed uninspired. But even with all the bad decisions and missteps, there were two moments of pure magic when Julie Andrews did what she does best and, alone on stage, sang a beautiful "Crazy World" in Act One and a lovely new song, written for the show by Frank Wildhorn, called "Living in the Shadows" near the end of Act Two. Audience response was enthusiastic, with a loud standing ovation for Andrews, but, by that time, I just wanted to go home. By the way, the friends accompanying me that afternoon felt the same, so it wasn't just me. Now I know many people will disagree on my assessment for Victor/Victoria. The reason this made my top ten list of theatrical train wrecks is simply because the film was such a textbook blueprint for a stage transfer and the creative team, for whatever reason, ignored what was staring them in the face and tried to reinvent the wheel, so to speak, to poor results. I suspect I would have felt quite differently had the show hewed more closely to the film. Just my humble opinion.
Sidebar: Victor/Victoria opened in New York to decidedly mixed/negative reviews, but with raves for Andrews, and ran for over 700 performances. Julie Andrews was in the show for most of its run, taking a month off for vacation, with Liza Minnelli filling in, but had to leave the show in June, 1997, when she developed vocal problems. Raquel Welch replaced her, and if anyone was in any doubt about who the draw was, it became apparent when box-office receipts tanked with Welch in the lead and the show closed four weeks later at a loss. But the big drama of the entire run, and, quite possibly of the 1995-1996 theatrical season, was Julie Andrews' announcement that she was refusing her Tony nomination as Best Actress in a musical and would not accept the award should she win because of, in her words, her "egregiously overlooked" cast and production staff. Her nomination was the show's only one, an odd state of affairs considering the other nominees in the musical categories, most especially in the Best Musical category. Seriously, Swinging on a Star? Chronicle of a Death Foretold? It was a brave stand by a classy lady and pretty much guaranteed the loss of what probably would have been her win. Donna Murphy won instead for a revival of The King and I. Sadly, after a botched operation to removed non-cancerous throat nodules in 1997, the once silken voice will never grace another musical.  

That's if for today. Part Two coming soon!
© 2015 Jeffrey Geddes

Sunday, June 14, 2015

MUSICAL MAYHEM: MY TOP TWENTY-FIVE MUSICALS The Honor Roll - Part 5

MUSICAL MAYHEM: MY TOP TWENTY-FIVE MUSICALS
The Honor Roll - Part 5

Two more musicals from the Honor Roll of my top twenty-five musicals. One is a Tony winner and the other is an all-but-forgotten show. I can't wait to get started, so let's begin.

THEY'RE PLAYING OUR SONG – Book by Neil Simon, Music by Marvin Hamlisch, Lyrics by Carole Bayer Sager
Without a care in the world and without a mean or serious bone in its musical theatre body, bless its heart, They're Playing Our Song plays like a refreshing breeze on a still, humid day or a thirst-quenching drink on a hot summer afternoon. Oh, sure, our protagonists have a very up-and-down relationship and it even threatens to, gasp!, dissolve, but trust Messrs. Simon and Hamlisch and Ms. Sager to prevent anything like that to happen. It does provide the background for the show's best ballad, "I Still Believe in Love," but even as Sonia pours her heart out in this stellar song, you just know it will all work itself out by the final curtain. I'm devoted to this show. I adore the score, even though with only ten numbers, including one reprise, it's a bit thin song-wise by musical standards, and Neil Simon's book is often just flat-out hysterical and I still get the giggles when I think of that classic line "Look how much your cane loves you!" Dated? Absolutely. It has a sweetness and eagerness to please that musicals today often don't have in their desire to be more than escapist entertainment (this seaon's closed-way-too-soon Honeymoon in Vegas is an exception). There's no message. There's no hidden agenda. They're Playing Our Song simply invites you to sit back, enjoy some great music, laugh at some great one-liners and leave the theatre smiling. That truly works for me.
Sidebar: I know I'm centuries too old, but I've always wanted to play one of the Voices and not necessarily one of Vernon's voices. Sonia's voices have more sass, but I'd gladly play in either group. Despite a run of nearly 1200 performances, this show has never had a Broadway revival. Heeeeellllloooo?? I can think of several potential revival casts off the top of my head. Fun fact: Stockard Channing, yes that Stockard Channing, was a replacement Sonia during the Broadway run.








March, 1979. Just six weeks after it opened to a set of mostly positive reviews (what's not to love, I ask?), They're  Playing Our Song looked like a shiny new coin and played like a million bucks. In 1979, Robert Klein was arguably the bigger name, and as such had the "star" left-side billing, and he played his part with enthusiasm and an earnestness that was both endearing and a bit goofy. He was immensely likeable. By contrast, however, it was clearly evident from the moment she made her entrance that Lucie Arnaz, in her Broadway debut, owned the Imperial stage. Now mind you, she never, ever overshadowed her co-star and she always, always was in sync with Klein, but she had a presence that just told you this was one Broadway newcomer to watch. Perhaps this charisma is in her genes, being the daughter of Desi Arnaz and Lucille Ball. Or perhaps it's that the role of Sonia is arguably the better role with the not-arguably more-soaring power ballads. I suspect it's a combination of both. No matter. They were both sensational and I laughed heartily and applauded like mad. Patricia Birch did the choreography, the high point being the joyful title song; Robert Moore provided the seamless direction; pros Douglas W. Schmidt, Ann Roth and Tharon M usser designed everything (scenic, costumes and lights respectively).  I  became an instant fan. – at the Imperial Theatre, New York.




April, 1979. Well, I loved the show so much, I went back two days later to catch an Actors Fund performance on that Sunday evening. An Actors Fund performance is a special performance given by shows nationwide to benefit the Actors Fund of America, a nationwide charitable organization that offers services and help to people in the entertainment industry. In New York, these performances are typically held on an "off" night, so folks involved in other shows can come cheer their friends and colleagues. Back in 1979, Sunday evenings on Broadway were dark. With an audience filled with industry friends and colleagues, the show had an added element of excitement and you could feel the electricity flowing both ways across the footlights. During the interval, Ain't Misbehavin's Armelia McQueen chatted me up in the lobby. It was that kind of evening. – at the Imperial Theatre, New York




December, 1979. First preview of the First National Tour. The set used in the bows apparently wasn't ready, which, of course, didn't faze the talented men and women on the Shubert stage one bit. In a far cry from the soulful and somewhat dour Anthony Hope of Sweeney Todd, Victor Garber showed his comic chops with a suitably manic performance as Vernon Gersh. He was irresistible and a better singer than Klein. As Sonia, Chicago audiences were indeed blessed to see the incomparable Ellen Greene. Distinctive in voice and somewhat quirky in manner, Greene gave an entirely new dimension to Sonia. Where Arnaz's Sonia was earthbound and centered, Greene's was a bit more frantic and scattered, so when she got down to musical brass tacks with "Just For Tonight" and especially "I Still Believe in Lone," the result was devastating. A duplicate of the New York original, this had all the bells and whistles, except for that final set piece, and the Voices were all marvelous. – at the Shubert Theatre, Chicago.

Another rare extant ticket from pre-computer days. The Mezzanine is now called the Dress Circle. Lousy place to sit unless you're in the first few rows because the Mezzanine (nee First Balcony) overhang cuts off the top portion of the stage.

The program had a minor makeover between previews and performances.


February, 1980. By this time the curtain call set piece was in place and the company as a whole seemed relaxed and at home at the Shubert. The group of friends I was with all thought the performance was super. So did I. – at the Shubert Theatre, Chicago



March, 1980. My best friend, Pat, was with me at the first Chicago preview. In March, 1980, we were both in New York to perform at a word-processing conference. (Word processors!!) We had some time off and since this was Lucie Arnaz's last day in the show, we decided to pay TPOS a return visit. Broadway stalwart Tony Roberts was playing Vernon by this time. I've never found Roberts to be an especially compelling performer, but he's always reliably and consistently good, which is probably why he always works, and his performance was solid and professional. Curiously, Arnaz now occupied the "star" billing slot and for her final matinee, she truly proved the billing was well worth it. It didn't hurt, of course, that the theatre was filled with fans and well-wishers, but she really pulled out all the stops and gave a magnificent performance. Fun fact: Future two-time Tony Award winner Donna Murphy had joined the cast and played one of Sonia's voices.  – at the Imperial Theatre, New York




February, 1981. (updated from a previous blog post) I would have seen this show in any event, but the bonus for me here in London was the dual casting of Tony-winner Tom Conti, in a surprisingly accomplished musical comedy turn, as Vernon and especially Gemma Craven, whom I fell in love with in the underrated film The Slipper and the Rose as Sonia. She was a joy with keen comic timing and a big, rich voice that did justice to her songs. Her "I Believe in Love"… yum. London editions of American musicals often seem to be played at a slightly faster clip which refreshes most material, no matter how excellent, and breathes new energy into it. Such was the case here. The material crossed the pond successfully and the London cast album remains my preferred version. This Yank had a grand time. – at the Shaftesbury Theatre, London




June, 1981. So what's a girl to do when her mother was one of the greatest and most iconic entertainers of all time, her sister an Emmy-Oscar-Tony winner (a non-competitive Grammy Legend Award would come in 1990) and only slightly less iconic than their mother, and when, for both her mother and sister, last names are superfluous because, well, who else would you mean and especially when your name is brought up and people say, "Who? Oh! You mean the other daughter." Well, if you're Lorna Luft, you work hard at your craft, take over an established role in a long-running Broadway show, work in summer stock, accept concert engagements whenever possible, star in a national tour of a Broadway hit, and relish in surprising people when they discover just how talented you are. And that's exactly what Lorna Luft did in the Second National Tour of TPOS. All the familiar production elements were present on the Uihlein Hall stage, Richard Ryder was an engaging and likeable Vernon, but it was Lorna Luft who was the revelation. With all due respect to Misses Arnaz, Greene, and Craven, this was arguably the best acted and certainly the best sung Sonia that I have seen. Her Sonia had just enough quirkiness to make her fun, but shaded that with a touching vulnerability that made you root for her from the start. And vocally? Ms. Luft definitely knew her way around the songs, knew how to merge the lyrics and the music until you believed the song was written expressly for her. You shouldn't be surprised. After all, she is Judy Garland's daughter. The interesting thing, though, is even back then Liza often sounded and performed like her mom, but you only caught glimpses of Garland in Luft's performance and only if you were looking for it. Absolutely first-rate. – at Uihlein Hall, Milwaukee


December, 1981. Produced with Marriott's Lincolnshire Theatre's usual standards, this was an entertaining evening that was professional, well-acted, well-sung and had lots of energy, but wasn't especially memorable. Chicago favorite David H. Bell certainly did a credible job directing the endeavor, but it was one of those shows that  didn't particularly register one way or the other. – at Marriott's Lincolnshire Theatre, Lincolnshire IL



July, 1984. Good things always seemed to going on at the still-lamented Candlelight Dinner Playhouse in Summit. By far, Candlelight was best in show for non-city theatre. Producer Bill Pullinsi and his directors, designers and actors gave audiences Broadway-quality shows and TPOS was no exception. Robert Neches, who played Vernon, was one of Steve's clients and he was a delightful Vernon who was clearly having fun in the role. Opposite him was Paty Lombard in a solid performance as Sonia that echoed Lucie Arnaz's, but was, at the same time, her own interpretation. A young Hollis Resnick was one of Sonia's voices. Good food and great theatre. Can't beat that! – at the Candlelight Dinner Playhouse, Summit IL

*************************

TITANIC – Book by Peter Stone, Music and Lyrics by Maury Yeston
The pre-opening buzz was lethal. The technical problems were legion, frequently stopping the show mid-performance. Preview walkouts were numerous. The ten-million-dollar show didn't have an iceberg's chance in hell and most critics and theatre columnists predicted the show, like its namesake, would sink at its opening performance, if it made it there at all. But despite a legendarily hellish preview period, vicious pre-opening press on a daily basis, and neutral-to-negative notices, Titanic proved everyone wrong by winning five Tony Awards two months later, including Best Musical, Best Book of a Musical and Best Original Score, and ended up with a respectable, if, unfortunately, unprofitable, run of over 800 performances. It perhaps will never again receive a production like it's original one, but over time, the show has proven that first impressions can often be wrong and has become somewhat of a cult musical, admired for both its faults and for its magnificent virtues. This is not a perfect show.  It could use a sensitive trim and some well-thought-out character excision. There are simply too many people to keep track of and not all of them essential to the story. The storyline of 2nd Class passenger Alice Beane borders precariously on being unsympathetically annoying. The number that I'm sure the creatives thought would be the takeaway hit song, "Still," while certainly touching, has never particularly moved me. And sometimes the show just sort of creaks along. But then…ah, but then. Let's be honest. The sinking of the Titanic is still, over one hundred years later, a story that intrigues and captures the imagination of so many people. It's a human story of greed, hubris, ambition, love, bravery and courage that still resonates. Titanic's story shows us people at the best and at their worst. We, perhaps despite ourselves, get involved with this familiar story. We know some of our favorite characters will die, yet we still want the outcome to be different. And at the end, we are moved. And that's primarily due to Peter Stone's book and Maury Yeston's magnificent score. If you haven't listened to the cast recording lately, spend some time listening to the musical glories of this show. There are many treasures there, but none as great as the opening sequence of music that is the most thrilling opening of any show I've seen. This show beat the odds. For that, we should be thankful.
Sidebar: For the record, my other top favorite openings, in order are "Ragtime" from Ragtime, "Willkommen" from Cabaret (1998), "Walk Him Up the Stairs" from Purlie and "Willkommen" from Cabaret (1966).






December, 1998. As mentioned earlier, Titanic pretty much confounded its critics and not only won a bunch of Tony Awards, but also acquired a sizeable number of devoted fans and embarked on a very respectable two-year run. We saw this about twenty months after its opening. By then the show had long settled into its berth at the Lunt-Fontanne (sorry…I'll stop the shipboard references now) and the largely replacement cast of seasoned Broadway pros brought this sweeping tale to life. In the reviews, much was made of the intricate, yet not particularly opulent, scenic design…I suspected most reviewers were disappointed it wasn't more luxe...but I found the use of levels to reflect the various decks and the shipboard hierarchy to be effective. Most impressive was the scenic coup de théâtre in the First Class Smoking Room as the hydraulics worked overtime and furniture and actor Matthew Bennett, playing Titanic's architect, Thomas Andrews, tilted and slid offstage representing the ship as it sank. Really quite brilliant. Least impressive, the scenic "what-the-hell-were-they-thinking" use of a miniature Titanic zipping along the upstage wall at the conclusion of Act One, then disappearing offstage with a crash, symbolizing, I assume, the collision with the iceberg. Really rather silly and it elicited more than a few laughs, not the reaction the designers were aiming for, I suspect. In an otherwise elegant production, it was quite cheesy. The opening sequence soared; Martin Moran and Clarke Thorell shone in their duet "The Proposal/The Night was Alive;" John Cunningham provided years of Broadway experience as a noble Captain Smith; Adam Pelty made the most out of the eerie and prophetic "No Moon;" Jennifer Piech, Theresa McCarthy and Emily Loesser, daughter of composer Frank Loesser, were notable and feisty as the three Kates. Unfortunately, I felt Kay Walbye's Alice Beane was cloying and how much of that had to do with the performance itself and how much of it had to do with the writing of the part is debatable. I will say, however, that in the staged concert version, the character came across better. For the record, the Lunt's balcony is painfully tight. Poor Bob's leg were crushed. We took empty seats in the orchestra for Act Two. – at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, New York






(edited from a previous post)
February, 2014. Manhattan Concert Productions presented this. These are the same folks who produced last season's breathtaking concert edition of Ragtime. Last year's performance bordered on a religious experience; this year was no different. It was simply magnificent; a feast for the ears and the soul as Peter Stone and Maury Yeston brought the legendary tragic saga of the ill-fated R.M.S. Titanic to a human level, devoid of the special effects and stereotypes of James Cameron's much-lauded film. (Lest you get the wrong impression, I quite like Mr. Cameron's film. But it's often more spectacle than story.) From Captain to First Class Passenger to the Bellboy, director Don Stephenson and music director Kevin Stites gave us characters we may have loved or hated, Bruce Ismay was really a despicable human being, but we were interested in all of them and cared about many of them. As I've mentioned before, this is not a perfect show. Not every number lands: the Strauses' "Still," ably sung by Alma Cuervo and Ron Raines, tugs at our emotions, but doesn't quite touch us the way the authors intended; "I Give You My Hand," a beautiful song cut during Broadway previews, is pretty to listen to, but seems grafted onto the proceedings; "Mr. Andrews' Vision," while powerful, perhaps could have better made its point as a frantic spoken monologue, given the scenic/technical restraints of a staged concert production on a concert hall stage. But, then, ladies and gentlemen, there is that opening sequence: a glorious experience that ranks, in my book, as the most singular opening number in musical theatre. Ever. Full stop. According to the program, seven pieces of music make up this opening, ending with the goosebump-inducing "Godspeed Titanic," which also brings the show to its triumphant conclusion. It's a marvel of acting, singing, and, even in this concert setting, staging. Like last year, a 250-strong chorus added an extra thrilling element to the ensemble numbers. Many of the original cast members returned to reprise their roles and they were all greeted with enthusiastic "welcome home" entrance applause. This remarkable cast included, in addition to Ms. Cuervo and Mr. Raines, Michael Cerveris, David Constabile, John Bolton, John Cunningham, David Garrison, Jill Paice, Michele Ragusa, Ryan Silverman and other talented Broadway pros. Top honors, though went to David Elder as Frederick Fleet with a haunting "No Moon" to close Act One, Joseph Castinado, a high school junior, whose excitement at being in this production in the role of Bellboy was positively contagious and totally endearing, but most especially to Brian d'Arcy James (Frederick Barrett) and Martin Moran (Harold Bride) whose duet of "The Proposal/The Night Was Alive" stopped the show cold and when they appeared together at bows, brought the already loud and enthusiastic applause to a deafening roar of cheers and bravos. My good pal, Gina, joined me and she remarked that she'd seen nothing quite like this. I agree. - at Avery Fisher Hall, Lincoln Center, New York

That's it for now! Til later.
© 2015 Jeffrey Geddes


CONCERTS AND TUNERS AND PLAYS…OH, MY! - vol. 1

  CONCERTS AND TUNERS AND PLAYS…OH, MY! vol. 1 Spring is finally here. And what better way to celebrate than by strolling down theatrical ...